A Beginners Guide To Identifying Cincinnatian Crinoids

By Jack Kallmeyer

Back to Crinoid Menu

If you reached this web page from a web site about a potential Martian crinoid fossil, 
click here for a response from Jack Kallmeyer and Bill Heimbrock.

General Identification

Cincinnaticrinus varibrachialus


Courtesy of Bill Heimbrock

Coutesy of Jack Kallmeyer
Very small cup only slightly wider than the stem. Smooth cup plates. 

The arms above the cup branch evenly and repeatedly. The arms have no pinnules. 

The anal series is arm-like and branches off at the cup. 

Stems are very long and have a distinctive shape, see drawings. The majority of the stem is made of round columnals with rounded edges. The articulating surface of the columnals has a five lobed design. The stem becomes smaller and pentagonal near the cup. 

The holdfast type is Lichenocrinus. 

This species is found in the Kope and Fairview. 

Click here to see 3-D views of this specimen!

 

Cincinnaticrinus pentagonus 


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
Differs from C. variabrachialus in that the size of the cup is the same width as the stem. The stems and cups get larger in general than the C. varibrachialus of the Kope Formation. It is found in the Maysvillian and Richmondian. 

Another Cincinnaticrinus pentagonus photo

 

Merocrinus


Courtesy of John Tate

Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
This species found in the lower Kope has a small cup considering the size of its stems. The cup plates are smooth and the arms branch evenly and repeatedly. The anal series is arm-like and branches off the top of the cup. The cups seem to be fairly uncommon even within large pockets of stem pieces. 

Stems are round in cross section and very smooth. The columnals are thinner. The stem appears to taper and become thinner near the cup. Stem diameter can exceed 5 mm. Merocrinus uses a coiled stem type of holdfast.

 

Ectenocrinus simplex


Courtesy of Bill Heimbrock 
Another very common crinoid in the Kope. It is also found into the Maysvillian. 

The cup is made of smooth plates. The arms are long and branch only once just above the cup. The arms bear rammules which look much like pinnules except the rammules are larger. When found as complete crowns, the arms are generally folded inward hiding the ramules. 

The stem is round and quite long (see drawing). The stem immediately below the cup tapers rapidly and is made of very thin columnals. 

 

Iocrinus subcrassus


Courtesy of Carolyn Greene (#1) and Jack Kallmeyer (#2)
The cup of this crinoid found throughout the Cincinnatian is fairly small and has ridges aligned with the ridges of the stem. The arms branch many times above the cup. The anal sac is somewhat ornate.

The stem is pentagonal to star shaped with prominent articulating ridges (see drawing). This is another type of crinoid using a coiled stem as a holdfast.

 

Plicodendocrinus casei

Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer

A very distinctive form found in the Waynesville and Liberty of the Richmondian. Cups are highly ornate with stellate ridges. This was formerly known as Dendrocrinus casei

The arms are narrower than the cup plates where they attach. 

The anal sac is large and ornamented with star shaped ridges which makes this species identifiable from fragments of this alone. 

The stem is star shaped with very faint articulating ridges. It tapers rapidly below the cup. This species uses radicular cirri as a holdfast (see drawing). 

Recent finds in the Kope may extend the range of this species to that formation as well. 


 

Dendrocrinus caduceus


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
Another Richmondian form. This species has a smooth cup with three depressions around it. The arms are narrower than the cup plates where they attach.

I have not yet determined the stem, anal sac, or holdfast type.
 

 

Pychnocrinus dyeri



Courtesy of Bill Heimbrock





Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
Yet another highly ornamented form with the cup having stellate ridges. The cup shape is somewhat globular. The arms branch once above the cup resulting in twenty arms bearing abundant pinnules. 

The stem is round with large diameter columnals alternating with small diameter ones (see drawing). 

P. dyeri is found in the Maysvillian and into the lower Richmondian. 


 

Glyptocrinus decadactylus


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
Very similar to Pychnocrinus dyeri in all regards. The most obvious difference is the distance between the division of the main ridges on the cup. In this species, the distance is small. On P. dyeri, it is twice as far.

This species is restricted to the Fairmount.

 

Glyptocrinus fornschelli


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
The cup is conical to globular and ornamented with ridges and small nodes.

The stem is most distinctive being pentagonal with extremely sharp corners (see drawing). The individual columnals are fairly thin, becoming very thin beneath the cup.

This appears to be a Liberty form.
 

 

Another Glyptocrinid

 I have recently found this crinoid (not pictured) in the Kope along with Cincinnaticrinus varibrachialus, Ectenocrinus simplex, and a Dendrocrinid. I have not yet identified it specifically.

The cup is decorated with stellate ridges on the lowest plates and fine nodes on the remaining plates. The arms bear pinnules. The stem resembles that of Glyptocrinus except that the larger diameter columnals have ten nodes protruding around the perimeter.

The holdfast is a coiled stem type.

 

Gaurocrinus nealli




This is another attractive crinoid with long pinulate arms.  The calyx can exceed 10 mm in height.  Gaurocrinus can be found in the Upper Waynesville and Liberty Formations.

The cup has very prominent ray ridges that branch once on the calyx and at least one more time above it.  The anal ridge is seen as a raised ridge along the side of the calyx.  Gaurocrinus is a diplobathrid camerate crinoid meaning that the cup is composed of three levels of plates.  The calyx plates between the raised ridges are small and irregular in size and shape.

The stems are pentagonal in shape and vary in diameter depending upon position.  See stem descriptions for details.

Gaurocrinus used a wrapped stem type of holdfast.

 

Rhaphanocrinus sculptus


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
The pictured specimen is an adult Rhaphanocrinus sculptus with two small juvenile specimens on the upper left side of the adult.  Note that the juveniles have relatively smooth cups.
This ornate little crinoid appears to be somewhat rare.  Miami University, the Field Museum and the Smithsonian seem to be the only institutions that have any at all and they only have five between them.  These crinoids have been found in the Upper Waynesville and Lower Liberty Formations.

Rhaphanocrinus was originally mis-classified as a Glyptocrinus (a monobathrid camerate) because it seemed to have only two levels of plates composing the cup.  It was later re-described when the third level of plates (lowest) was found to be present but hidden by the level above them.  When you see this crinoid you will see how easy it is to make that error.  The basal plates (the middle level) project out over the stem with spectacular ridges and hide the lower infrabasals.

The most obvious features are the very high narrow ray ridges that begin at the basal plates.  These ridges stand out vertically away from the calyx as if they were knife blades.  The plates between the ray ridges also have smaller ridges.  The adult crowns do not have an anal ridge on the side of the calyx.  The tegman (covering of the top of the calyx within the arm circle) is composed of many tiny plates.  The heavy ornamentation on the calyx is missing from the smallest individuals so that there is a gradation of ornamentation from the smallest to the largest individuals.

The arms of Rhaphanocrinus are round and carry pinnules.

The stem is pentalobate with the diameter varying with position along the stem.  Columnals nearest to the cup are more circular as are the smallest diameter columnals.

Rhaphanocrinus used a coiled stem type of holdfast.


Xenocrinus baeri


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer

This is a small to medium sized crinoid. The cup has prominent ridges which lead up to the arms. The plates of the cup between these ridges are small and have a small node on each one. The arms bear pinnules.

The most unique feature of this species is the "square" stem shap (see drawing). Echinoderms usually have a five-fold symmetry which is why this one is so unusual.

X. baeri is found in the Liberty and Whitewater of the Richmondian. The genus is also found in Europe.


 

Cupulocrinus polydactylus


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
This species is easily identified by the distinctive nature of the cup plates. The plates are smooth but bulge outward (convex) making the conical cup resemble a small bunch of grapes. 

The arms are wide and branch numerous times above the cup. It is non-pinnulate. 

The stem is smooth, round and tapers gradually away from the cup. I believe the stems to be very short - since Cuplulocrinids from other areas have stems less than 100 mm long. 

C. polydactylus can be found from the Waynesville through the Whitewater of the Richmondian. 

 

Anomalocrinus incurvus  


Courtesy of Univ of Cinti,
Photo by Jack Kallmeyer
By far the largest Cincinnatian crinoid with cups over 40 mm wide and stems up to 15 mm in diameter. 

The cup is almost spherical and smooth. The robust arms are narrower at their base than the cup plates that they attach to. 

The holdfast is a distinctive encrusting type of large size which can display "root-like" extensions. 

This crinoid had previously been thought to inhabit high energy environments and was typically found in the Bellevue of the Maysvillian. More recent discoveries are yielding specimens down into the Kope. 

 

Canistrocrinus typus


Courtesy of Jack Kallmeyer
I don't have any descriptive information on this one yet.

 

Other Crinoid Identifications

Stem Identification
Holdfast Identification

Sign Our Guest Book!

Return to Home Page

The Dry Dredgers and individual contributors reserve the rights to all information, images, and content presented here. Permission to reproduce in any fashion, must be requested in writing to admin@drydredgers.org.